top of page

What You Need to Know About the Digital ID Bill: Pros, Cons, and Forecast

digital id

The Digital ID Bill is a legislative proposal aimed at establishing a comprehensive framework for the creation, management, and authentication of digital identities.The bill addresses the need for a standardised and supposedly secure digital identification system.

The government introduced legislation in the parliament in 1986 to introduce an Australian identity card, but it failed, due to public sentiment and was repeatedly blocked by the opposition and minor parties.

myGov Digital ID has now passed the first of three stages in Australia. The myGovID system collects, uses, stores and discloses personal information.

The Australian Business Registry Services required a digital ID to be set up before applying for a Directors' ID if a person wants to become a company director. Ten million Australians were forced to do this or relinquish their director status. 

As we analyse the Digital ID Bill, it's essential to acknowledge the ongoing digital transformation shaping our societies. The increasing reliance on digital platforms for transactions, services, and communication necessitates a secure and efficient digital identification system. However, the proposed bill requires careful consideration due to its far-reaching implications.

Digital ID Proposed Objectives

The Digital ID Bill aims to set common standards for digital identity verification across various sectors. This includes financial services, healthcare, government interactions, and more.

Promoting seamless interaction between different digital identity systems is a key focus. The bill encourages interoperability to ensure that digital identities can be verified across diverse platforms and services.

Recognising the sensitivity of personal information, the bill prioritises privacy. It outlines clear guidelines on the collection, storage, and sharing of digital identity data, aligning with contemporary privacy regulations. 

To mitigate the risks associated with identity theft and fraud, the bill proposes robust security 

measures, such as multi-factor authentication and encryption protocols.

Challenges and Considerations

Security and Privacy Concerns

Data Breach Risks -  The centralization of digital identity information raises concerns about the potential for large-scale data breaches. A single point of failure could expose a vast amount of sensitive data, compromising the privacy and security of individuals.

Surveillance Risks - The aggregation of personal information within a digital identity system may lead to increased surveillance. Individuals might have limited control over how their data is used, shared, or accessed. This lack of autonomy could potentially lead to unwarranted surveillance and a sense of vulnerability among the public.

Inclusivity and Accessibility

Digital Divide - Implementation of a digital identity system may inadvertently deepen the digital divide, excluding individuals who lack access to technology or are not digitally literate. This could disproportionately affect marginalised communities and hinder their ability to participate fully in the digital economy.

Exclusionary Biometrics - The reliance on biometric data for authentication may present challenges for individuals with disabilities or those whose biometric information is difficult to capture accurately.

Cost and Implementation Challenges

Infrastructure Costs - Implementing and maintaining a secure digital identity infrastructure involves substantial costs. This may pose challenges for smaller businesses and governments with limited resources.

Integration Complexity - Integrating digital identity systems with existing infrastructures poses technical challenges, and the transition may disrupt current operations. A gradual and well-planned transition strategy is essential to mitigate these disruptions.

International Alignment

Cross-Border Trust -  Establishing cross-border trust in digital identities requires harmonization of standards, and achieving consensus among nations with different regulatory approaches will be challenging. Not to mention that the data will be exposed to  even bigger privacy concerns and worldwide cyberattacks.

Potential for Misuse 

Even with a well-intentioned legislative framework and regulatory body in place, there's always the risk of the system being used for purposes beyond its original intent. Mission creep, where the system and department expands to cover more aspects of people's lives, could lead to unintended consequences. Critics argue that the potential for abuse and misuse by authorities or other entities should not be underestimated. 

Deleting your Digital ID 

You can delete or uninstall the myGovID app from your device, however this will not delete your registered digital identity.

The Long Term Impact

Business Landscape

Prospective Positive Impact - Enhanced security measures may contribute to a reduction in cybercrime and fraud, creating a more trustworthy digital environment for businesses. Streamlining processes through interoperability could lead to increased efficiency and productivity.

Potential Negative Impact - The centralised nature of digital identities could present an attractive target for cyberattacks, potentially leading to large-scale data breaches. Implementation costs and compliance requirements may disproportionately affect smaller businesses, creating barriers to entry and stifling competition.

Families and Individuals

Prospective Positive Impact - A well-implemented Digital ID Bill could empower individuals to manage and control their personal data, fostering a sense of agency in the digital realm. This empowerment could result in increased confidence in online interactions and transactions.

Potential Negative Impact - The erosion of privacy could lead to a loss of trust. Individuals may become hesitant to engage in digital activities, impacting their ability to fully participate in the modern digital economy.

Health Professionals

Prospective Positive Impact - In the long term, a standardised digital identity system could streamline access to patient records, facilitating faster and more accurate healthcare services. This efficiency might contribute to advancements in medical research and treatment.

Potential Negative Impact - Privacy concerns in healthcare are particularly sensitive. Unauthorised access to medical records could lead to severe consequences, losing trust in digital systems and hindering the adoption of beneficial technologies.

Strategic Considerations for Long-Term Success

  • A robust public education campaign is essential to inform individuals about the benefits and potential risks associated with the Digital ID Bill. This campaign should be comprehensive, engaging, and accessible to ensure widespread understanding.

  • It is crucial to underscore the inherent right of individuals to choose whether or not to participate in a digital identity system. The essence of a democratic society lies in the freedom to make choices, and the imposition of a digital identity system should not compromise this principle. The Digital ID Bill should not be a mandate but rather an offering where individuals willingly choose to create their Digital ID.

  • Individuals who choose not to participate in the digital identity system should not face stigmatization in society or government institutions. Respecting individual choices ensures a democratic and inclusive approach to digital identity adoption.

  • Deleting a digital identity should be a straightforward process that respects user autonomy and ensures the secure removal of personal information. Users can delete or uninstall the myGovID app from their device, however this will not delete their registered digital identity which is a concern. To discuss deleting their myGovID so it can no longer be used, users need to call the support line which is not a recommendable or advanced solution in any type or form.

  • Recognizing the concern about the complexity of deleting a registered digital identity, there is a need for a more user-friendly and accessible process. The Digital ID Bill should mandate the development of straightforward mechanisms that allow users to delete their digital identity without unnecessary hurdles.

  • The process of deleting a digital identity should be communicated transparently to users. Clear guidelines on the steps involved, implications, and any subsequent actions required should be provided to ensure users are well-informed.

bottom of page